Lord Nimmo Smith, on Wednesday considered a fine and fair legal mind, became a ‘Rangers fan’ according to one Celtic supporter on STV and a lot worse on social media. The rulings come in the wake of Lord Nimmo Smith’s independent inquiry which saw the SFA charge Rangers and Whyte with seven breaches of its rules. “Rangers ceased to be a club” – Lord Nimmo Smith. Lord Nimmo Smith has left people exasperated. The Linkage between The UEFA Licence 2011 and the Lord Nimmo Smith Commission in 2012/2013. If you disagree with the opinion of these people and the company law of this country then you are quite frankly, an idiot. It was incorporated in 1899 as The Rangers Football Club Limited. Oldco Rangers were issued with a £250,000 fine but the club avoided the ultimate sanction of being stripped of titles after an independent commission – chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith … Lord Nimmo Smith’s commission, which begins today, decides whether Rangers told the football authorities about the money they paid players as part of a tax avoidance scheme. It is to Lord Nimmo Smith's credit that he examined minutely the evidence presented and tried to base his findings impartially. Scottish Sun branded Nimmo Smith “Nimmo the Dimmo” over Magic Circle gay sex for justice investigation. It is interesting therefore to compare the following from the LNS Commission in respect of sanctions against Rangers FC for a breach covering ten years of incorrect registration with the sanctions against both Clyde FC over 2 games and Hearts over one game, based on what Lord Nimmo Smith said in his findings at 107 and 108 of his Decision. Thanks Neil Martin then wheels out the rickety old ASA/UEFA ‘argument’. The Scottish Football Association, in seeking to defend itself from allegations that it unfairly awarded Rangers a licence to play in Europe in 2011/2012, appears to have admitted that it withheld evidence from the Lord Nimmo Smith inquiry into rule breaking by the club in its use of tax avoidance schemes. Whatever Happened to the Nimmo Smith Report? Nimmo Smith in his judgement also criticised the directors of old Rangers for failing to follow rules on disclosing payments. An independent commission has begun its investigation into whether Rangers football club failed to fully declare details of payments to players between 2000 and 2011. • Lord Nimmo Smith ii – SPL Dual Contract Tribunal 28th February 2013 It will be recalled that in Article 2 "Club" is defined in terms of "the undertaking of an association football club", and in Rule I1 it is defined in terms of an association football club which is, for the … ... A commission led by Lord Nimmo Smith … SFA may have misled Rangers tax… November 16, 2016. The rationale of the ASA was largely based on the Lord Nimmo Smith ruling as well as submissions from RIFC/Sevco that the European Club Association considered them to be the same club. However, its timeline is too short to include any of the accusations about rule breaking before the Craig Whyte era. An independent commission chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith, ruled in 2013 that Rangers HAD breached regulations by failing to disclose the payments. “But Lord Nimmo Smith said Rangers FC continues to exist.” Not really. LNS’ Reasons for Decision dated 12th September 2012, had a specific purpose. He was clarifying the definition of “football club,” for the purposes of the SPL investigation into Rangers’ use of dual contracts. I doubt it and I firmly believe that every decent football fan, right thinking person and impartial observer will agree with me. At the end of the show the issue of whether Rangers were a “new club” was discussed in the context of an agenda by certain people in the media. This was down wholly to the evidence of the SFA’s Sandy Bryson. Rangers – incorrectly, in Lord Nimmo Smith’s decision – took the view that they did not need to file them with the SPL because they weren’t about payments to players. He categorically did not question Nimmo Smith’s impartiality but stated that the process was flawed if Nimmo Smith was working on behalf of his client who had a pre determined agenda. It owed substantial amounts to HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC), who subsequently refused to allow Rangers to exit administration via a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA). For Rangers and their supporters, the findings of Lord Nimmo Smith and his three-man independent commission brought … Lacking intelligible meaning: a nonsensical jumble of words. HMRC is appealing the judgement on the remaining cases. GT: “The report focuses on the way the SFA handled the financial crisis at Rangers and the regulatory questions which arose from that. Dr Gregory Ioannidis, a leading authority on Sports Law, agrees that “the history of a club cannot pass from one company [into liquidation]to another”. Celtic quickly stated that they expected the Scottish football authorities to review the case - a 2013 commission appointed by the Scottish Premier League and led by judge Lord Nimmo Smith ruled that Rangers received "no unfair competitive advantage'' after failing to disclose "side letters'' detailing the contentious payments, in breach of SPL rules. It would also be a good time to re-visit Res11/12 and the sham Lord Nimmo Smith enquiry and the 8 or 9 titles the old huns won when they were using EBTs. He said: "In terms of the question about old club, new club, that was settled very much by the Lord Nimmo Smith commission that was put together by … Lord Nimmo Smith is a top Law Lord with 40 years experience and this was his summary on the topic in a legal enquiry for the SPL who were the owners of the Football League Rangers … A commission led by Judge Lord Nimmo Smith had previously ruled that Rangers had gained ‘no sporting advantage’ over their use of EBTs, but this was heavily influenced by the first tier tribunal result – which Rangers won. He was clarifying the definition of “football club,” for the purposes of the SPL investigation into Rangers’ use of dual contracts. But Lord Nimmo Smith, who headed the investigation, said Rangers should not be stripped of titles won between 2001 and 2010. Within that review, Nimmo Smith confirmed that under the SFA Rules continuity existed within the Private Articles of Association, and that Rangers we in fact the same club. The club, trading as The Rangers Football Club plc, entered administration in February 2012. The SFA too were in the business of cunningly narrowing a remit in order to achieve a predetermined outcome. The Scottish football media's stunning EBT gymnastics. LORD NIMMO SMITH and CHARLES FLINT QC (from the Tribunal Report) “On the 14th of June 2012 a newly incorporated company, Sevco Scotland Ltd., purchased substantially all the business and assets of Oldco, INCLUDING RANGERS FC” It found that 'oldco' did not disclose payments to the football authorities. Rangers lose EBT side letters appeal as… The accompanying graphic shows the club titles that are under threat. The Scottish Football Association has appointed Lord William Nimmo Smith to chair its inquiry into recent activities at Rangers. We look at two specific things: the Lord Nimmo Smith inquiry, which looked into rulebreaking by Rangers Football Club, and the grant of a licence to play in Europe in the 2011/12 season. He retired on 30 September 2009. Nimmo Smith married Jennifer Main in 1968, with whom he has a son and a daughter, the novelist Harriet Tyce. He was Chairman of the Council of the Cockburn Association from 1996 to 2001, being succeeded in this position by fellow judge Lord Brodie. The two governing bodies in Scottish football, the SPL and the SFA, agreed to hold a previous inquiry into the Rangers EBT era; it was led by Lord Nimmo Smith. Although better informed as a result of his conversation with Andrew Dickson on 6 th December 2011 in respect of the unlawfulness of DOS EBTS, where HMRC were pursuing the non-payment of proper tax under PAYE terms, SFA CEO Stewart Regan met Lord Nimmo Smith … Rangers had already faced some punishment for its use of EBTs. How does one marry the concept that Rangers could run an off the books wage payment scheme that lowered their tax bill and contravened the SFA’s registration rules with the concept that the rules were unfit to be applied and that no competitive advantage was gained from it? Lord Nimmo Smith has been forced to consider as legal an EBT scheme at Rangers which a further tribunal may well rule as illegal - that would have to make a difference to Lord Nimmo Smith’s reasoning if, perhaps not his overall judgement. I’m not going to go into why we are the same Rangers, it’s an argument that’s been had a million times over and I will take the word of the SFA, SPFL, ASA, UEFA, FIFA and Lord Nimmo-Smith over that of any bitter rival support any day. Lord Nimmo Smith. Mar 5, 2021. The Rangers scandal has damaged Scottish football on a massive scale. LNS asserts that the Club “Rangers FC” was owned & operated by Rangers Football Club plc. Lord Nimmo Smith has accepted the terms of reference as “facts”. cal (nn-sns-kl) adj. Nimmo Smith enquiry and EBT verdicts In late 2012, the SPL set up an investigation, chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith , into alleged use of dual contracts by Rangers through the EBT scheme. Administration and liquidation of The Rangers Football Club Plc: | |Rangers|, a |football| club in Scotland, entered financial difficulties during the late ... World Heritage Encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive collection ever assembled. In 2000 the company’s name was changed to The Rangers Football Club PLC, and on 31 July 2012 to RFC 2012 PLC. As Lord Nimmo Smith describing the documentary commented :-This event appears to have been the trigger for more activity in response to the SPL’s request. These were important documents pertinent to Lord Nimmo Smith’s inquiry into Rangers use of EBTs, documents which had not been made available to Harper MacLeod by Rangers Administrators Duff and Phelps despite being requested in March 2012 as part of … or penalty should be imposed on Rangers FC.” Lord Nimmo Smith — who chaired a commission set up by the SPL — ruled the club failed to declare EBT payments made to … Lord Nimmo Smith's commission investigating alleged undisclosed payments to Rangers players begins today. :confused:Whats the point of fineing old Rangers [ a liquidated company] £250000.00, seemingly the newco don't have to pay . Rangers has maintained that it is "Scotland's most successful football club" as the advertising campaign making the claim is probed by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA). Lord Nimmo Smith Enquiry. It was incorporated in 1899 as The Rangers Football Club Limited. The SPL articles and rules apply to Clubs and to their “owners & operators”. From 1983 to 1986, he was an Advocate Depute, representing … The on-line Scottish football community prepared itself, demonstrating that, whatever the findings “outrage” would be the one guaranteed result. Rangers have also been fined a total of £160,000 while Whyte, who had already been deemed unfit to hold an official position in the game by the SFA, was handed fines totalling £200,000. Rangers are the same club that existed before liquidation, says SPFL chief executive Neil Doncaster. What Lord Nimmo Smith was disgusted at was the vitriolic lynch mob hysteria demanding he ignore any evidence and just decree against Rangers in every point possible. However, the three-man panel, chaired by judge Lord Nimmo Smith, ruled Rangers had gained no "unfair competitive advantage" and should suffer no sporting sanction. Hugh Dallas needed stitches for a head wound. Lord Nimmo Smith SPL Tribunal investigating Rangers When oldco went into liquidation it was claimed that 140 years of history were lost. The SPL revealed the commission appointed in relation to “RFC 2012 Plc (now in liquidation) and Rangers FC and chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith” would … Hon. “In the interests of good governance it was absolutely right that this was the case.” On 21 st February 2012 the SFA announced that it had appointed retired judge Lord Nimmo Smith to chair an independent inquiry into Rangers FC. The reason for the commission sitting was the alleged non-disclosure of payments to players at Rangers … Lord Nimmo Smith's three-man panel found the club guilty of failing to properly disclose side-letter arrangements between 2000 and 2011. Rangers say it is "ridiculous" to expect them to foot the bill. His first name also crept in. Rangers lost their long-running dispute over the employee benefits trusts (EBT) tax avoidance scheme after judges ruled in favour of HMRC. "Lord Nimmo Smith has said that Rangers FC is a recognisable entity which continued in existence notwithstanding the change in ownership," said Green. LNS asserts that the Club “Rangers FC” was owned & operated by Rangers Football Club plc. Legal career. Rangers have also been fined a total of £160,000 while Whyte, who had already been deemed unfit to hold an official position in the game by the SFA, was handed fines totalling £200,000. Good Afternoon. Rangers owner Craig Whyte 'is not considered to be a fit and proper person to hold a position within association football', according to the SFA. It was incorporated in 1899 as The Rangers Football Club Limited. The most recent trending acronym after a Twitter hashtag is LNS. Oldco Rangers were fined £250,000 for contravening disclosure rules but the club escaped the most severe sanction of losing league titles won during the period. 1. Lord Sutherland and Lord Nimmo Smith released Hodge, of Denibigh Road, Coventry, on bail and ordered him to carry out 240 hours' community service instead. Luckily Krys reminded me at the end, so we got a chance to discuss Lord Nimmo Smith’s decision to fine Rangers (oldco) £250k, but not strip them of SPL titles. They also include a visit last year to William Nimmo-Smith, the QC asked by the Lord Advocate to investigate the alleged gay ''Magic Circle'' among Scottish lawyers and the judiciary. The 8th anniversary of the Lord Nimmo Smith enquiry - Rangers keep their trophies. SPFL: Rangers are the same club post-liquidation ... that was settled very much by the Lord Nimmo Smith commission that was put together by the SPL to look at EBT payments at that time. The parameters of this work have not been made public to my knowledge. Rangers, a football club in Scotland, entered financial difficulties during the late 2000s. The only thing that can save it is justice. The Lord Nimmo Smith (LNS) Commission, established in 2012 by the SPL to investigate the use by Rangers Football Club (RFC) of Employee Benefit Trusts with side letters, was derailed and duped – deliberately or otherwise – by the inexplicable failure to supply already existing evidence of earlier ‘irregular’ RFC EBTs. ). Bridie Bhoy said: Sorry pal, but I do believe that Lord Nimmo Smith declared that spending more money than other people definitely does NOT give you any sporting advantage whatsoever, as gleefully reported by the Daily Rangers, The Sun, the BBC, STV and every other media outlet in Scotland! Lord Nimmo Smith, fined RFC 2012 PLC (previously The Rangers Football Club plc) (in liquidation)) ("Rangers Oldco") the sum of £250,000 in respect of multiple breaches of SPL and Scottish FA Rules. It broke the news that 'same club' Sevco are going to have to pay the £250,000 fine levied on a different club following the deliberations of the Lord Nimmo Smith Commission. Yes, that would seem about right for the decision that was made by The RT Hon Lord Nimmo Smith, Nicholas Stewart QC and Charles Flint QC on behalf of the SPL this morning in regards to the investigation into the following: [1] For […] JPDT/LNS Timeline Dec 2011 to April 2012 6th Dec 2011: Stewart Regan SFA CEO and Andrew Dickson Rangers FC Football administrator converse about the wee tax liability of £2.8m arising in March 2011 and the circumstances of its granting. Quite rightly, Rangers CEO has challenged the SPL and SFA over their predetermined agenda to strip Rangers of titles and trophies. In 2000 the company’s name was changed to The Rangers … The Right Honourable Lord William Nimmo Smith. Read the rest of this entry → The SPL set up the commission to investigate whether the old Rangers FC broke rules over payments to players between 2000 and 2011. In 2000 the company’s name was changed to The Rangers Football Club PLC, and on 31 July 2012 to RFC 2012 PLC. Foolish; absurd: nonsensical ideas. Upon reading this article, I am reminded of Lord Nimmo Smith and the SFA inquiry into Rangers financial irregularities that he conducted. Previous: Part 4 . :confused: Rangers lost their long-running dispute over the employee benefits trusts (EBT) tax avoidance scheme after judges ruled in favour of HMRC. However, at the time of Lord Nimmo Smith's ruling, EBT payments were not considered to have been taxable earnings, a matter which led the law lord to rule that Rangers had not received a … The Scottish Football Association has appointed Lord William Nimmo Smith as chair of their independent inquiry into Rangers' recent business … At the recent meeting Rod McKenzie was questioned upon this aspect and confirmed that Lord Nimmo Smith had imposed a £250,000 fine on Rangers for the illegal registration of players. Lord Nimmo Smith was also wrong when he said that Rangers FC still exists. The Rangers … The two governing bodies in Scottish football, the SPL and the SFA, agreed to hold a previous inquiry into the Rangers EBT era; it was led by Lord Nimmo Smith. Unless you've been stuck on the moon over the last few days, you won't have failed to note another EBT hullabaloo has formed after leaked communications between Celtic and the SFA. Green … An independent commission chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith subsequently concluded as follows : Meanwhile, BBC Scotland came, by unknown means, into possession of what they described as “dozens of secret emails, letters and documents”, which we understand were … Rangers fans recognise that. Now this might be completely innocent but one can't quite … Rangers manager Ally McCoist feels “totally vindicated” by the report into the oldco club’s undisclosed payments after Lord Nimmo Smith and his colleagues ruled no … A Scottish Premier League investigation headed by Lord Nimmo Smith found Rangers guilty of not registering players properly and the company was fined in 2013. Rangers chief Green spoke out after SunSport revealed details of the plot to strip Gers of nine trophies. Nimmo Smith… I think what is most galling about the claims this is their 55th title is that 5 of them should have been struck off the record under the Lord Nimmo Smith Commission. Green was charged for alleged comments made regarding the integrity of the commission, chaired by Lord Nimmo Smith, which will investigate the Ibrox club's use of … In February 2013, an independent SPL commission, chaired by the Rt. As previously stated however, the club were fined – £250,000 – for the way the scheme was processed. Luckily Krys reminded me at the end, so we got a chance to discuss Lord Nimmo Smith’s decision to fine Rangers (oldco) £250k, but not strip them of SPL titles. FIFA, UEFA, the ASA, Lord Nimmo Smith, and countless others all recognise Rangers as the same club. Nevertheless, Lord Nimmo-Smith’s judgement is so extraordinary and bizarre it simply can’t pass without comment. It emerged late on Wednesday that the Lord Nimmo Smith-chaired enquiry would present its verdict at noon the next day. Lord Nimmo Smith has accepted the terms of reference as “facts”. In February 2013, an independent SPL commission, chaired by the Rt. A Scottish Premier League investigation headed by Lord Nimmo Smith found Rangers guilty of not registering players properly and the company was fined in 2013. The big issue here is not if Rangers were guilty or not. Surely Lord Drummond’s judgement now supersedes any ruling made by Nimmo Smith on EBTs being lawful with it now being null and void – based on a decision which has now been appealed and overturned. #7. Had Lord Nimmo Smith castigated Rangers for gaining the unfair sporting advantage that our enemies so passionately craved, would they be willing to draw the ‘line in the sand’ that they now so readily advocate? On 21 st February 2012 the SFA announced that it had appointed retired judge Lord Nimmo Smith to chair an independent inquiry into Rangers FC.
Morneau Shepell Pension, Coffee While Sick With Covid, 99205 Time Requirement 2021, Lost In Admiration Synonyms, Rush Street Interactive, Betmgm Withdrawal Not Working, John Hardy Mens Leather Bracelet, Kinesthetic Activities Examples, Cars Under $2,000 In Shreveport, Lofts For Rent Kansas City,